A Case Against Social Media
The manifesto
I have always felt an intuitive dislike for social media. With time, I made the conscious choice to avoid them altogether for the greater good of my creative goals and my personal growth and happiness.
A case against social media
Can an artist not use social media? Although many friends, among them successful artists and musicians, claim that social media are a way to connect to like-minded individuals and to cherish an audience, I believe this is not the only way to do it. For me the price to pay is too high, in terms of personal space of thoughts.
My suspicion that social media seriously interfere with our ability to do deep and meaningful work has been confirmed by computer scientist Cal Newport, as explained in much of his work. If you are not familiar with it, take a look at Deep Work.
Finally, centralized social media are unethical in my view, and I want to minimize my partaking in anything intrinsically evil. I look forward to new decentralized platforms. We used to have that in the 90s. It used to be websites.
Role models. It is much easier to try something arduous if you can see others succeeding at it. Some people never left the web of websites. Jaron Lanier, a computer scientist and musician who pioneered virtual reality, has no social media accounts and keeps a plain website of his own, and his book Ten Arguments for Deleting Your Social Media Accounts Right Now makes the case better than I can. My favorite is his second argument: quitting social media is “the most finely targeted way to resist the insanity of our times.” Cal Newport has never had a social media account and has written on his own site for years. The IndieWeb community works on the same principle: own your address and publish there first. This website is my version of that.
What it does to the work. The longer I stay away, the more I notice a second cost. Social media ask you to be recognizable at a glance: explain yourself quickly, keep the same tone, show glimpses of your life, be approachable in the expected way. Each step looks harmless. I worry that together they sand down the quieter, stranger and less certain parts of an artistic life, and that after enough repetition I would start choosing ideas for the persona instead of for the music. I want the work to arrive before the explanation.
One room for everyone. A joke among musicians, a thought shared with students and an invitation to strangers belong to different relationships. On a feed they all have to fit one public self, and something gets left out so that it travels easily.
To be fair. No medium leaves us untouched: a concert introduction, a photograph and this website also frame the encounter. Some artists make inventive use of these platforms, and a few seconds can hold a complete artistic idea. I respect that. I try to choose a form because it says something, and to notice when I am bending myself to a form only because it is expected.
If you are presenting my work. For the same reason I may decline a promotional script or a persona that does not fit the music. I am always happy to talk about an introduction that does.
Other ways to communicate: email! I see email as a superior way of communication, and I answer most of the emails I receive, even if it takes a lot of time (be patient). In particular, I answer all emails that come from anybody offering feedback or asking a question, musicians and possible collaborators, anyone involved in the digital art world, and anyone using SpaceEars.